Assessing the damage to your commercial door after a break-in is an unavoidably unpleasant task that will have you stressing about the expense and paperwork and lost time. We can’t do anything about the paperwork, but we can help you get back up and running as soon as possible.
Some damage to a commercial door can be repaired. Other damage puts the door beyond proper operation or out of code compliance and will require replacement.
To help you estimate what your door will require, we’ve put together this brief guide to when you can attempt a repair and when you should look at replacement.
The Key Factor: Proper Function and Security
The determining factor in whether to repair or replace a door after a break-in is whether the repair can restore proper functionality and security for your building.
Compliance
As you are no doubt aware, this means more than just whether the door closes and locks. Commercial doors can fall under several sets of codes, including the ADA, NFPA 80 Standards for Fire Doors, and NFPA 101 Life Safety Code. As such, you need to know about matters like door opening pressure, fire ratings and acceptable field modifications, and means of egress.
Cost
The second question is how much the repair will cost.
A rough industry rule of thumb is that, if the repair will cost 50% or more than replacing, it is worth replacing the part.
In other words, if you’re over halfway to replacing anyway, just bite the bullet and do it now rather than face potential wear-and-tear failures later that will accrue more expense.
Now, let’s look at the various parts of the full door assembly, or opening, that may have been affected by the break-in.
The Slab
The slab, or leaf, is the actual piece of metal or wood that makes a door a door. If the slab is sound, you may not have to replace anything other than hardware.
For wood doors, look for cracks or gouges, especially near the latch and hinges. For metal doors, look for dents and warping.
Pay specific attention to where any hardware attaches to the door. Has any hardware been pulled away from the door? Have any holes been stretched or stripped?
Any structural damage to the slab that affects the door’s ability to close, latch, and stay secure is more likely to mean replacement. This is especially true of a fire-rated door, which can only be modified in specific ways outlined in NFPA 80. Exterior doors along the fire exit route are always fire doors.
| Repair | Replace | |
| Wood slab | Cosmetic damage like divots or gouges that can be patched with wood filler and painted over. | Structural damage like cracks or holes |
| Metal slab | Minor dents | Holes, or major dents, stretching, or bending near any hardware |
Door Hardware
The Lockset
The lockset includes the latch, cylinder, knob or handle, deadbolt, strike plate, and any trim or decorative plates. Break-ins
typically target the lockset — it’s what’s keeping the door locked, after all — so it is common to need to replace it.
If any component is bent, warped, cracked, or otherwise broken, your best option is to replace it. A bent strike plate may be able to be bent back in place, but a handle that’s been cracked near the cylinder or spindle is likely too compromised.
Test the ease with which the handle or panic bar releases the latch. If there is more friction when you turn it or it requires more force than normal to turn, it may be in violation of the ADA. Sometimes cleaning and lubricating may be enough, but you’ll want someone trained in ADA compliance to have a look.
| Repair | Replace |
| Minor fixes that do not compromise the structural integrity or fire rating and allow it to operate normally | Broken or bent enough that it will never function adequately with any repair |
Electronic Access Control
You want to check both the mechanical and electronic parts of these components. Examine the housing for cracks or gaps where it has been pulled away from the surface. Oftentimes, you can replace a housing if the underlying circuitry still works, but it’s also important that the unit can be properly secured to the door or wall.
Test the electronics several times to make sure it opens the door consistently. Cut the power and make sure it behaves normally — usually it will be fail-secure on an exterior door, meaning that without power the door will remain locked. But, if it’s fail-safe, meaning it should unlock when the power is cut, then you’ll want to know it’s operating properly.
| Repair | Replace |
| If the unit functions properly and can be affixed to the door or wall without exposing any electronics | If the electronic parts are damaged, the lock does not operate consistently, or you have any of replacement indicators for a mechanical lockset (above) |
Door Closers
In many cases, these survive a break-in undisturbed. If, however, the closer is bent or pulled away from the door or frame, you’ll need to have a closer look.
Since entry doors are often both fire-rated and in the means of egress, most of them are under both NFPA 80 and NFPA 101 in addition to the ADA. Thus, if a closer can no longer release in an emergency, or if it creates too much resistance to open the door, then it’s out of compliance.
| Repair | Replace |
| Slight bending or simple remounting that does not affect performance | Any friction or warping that impedes smooth movement of the closer arms and/or door |
Hinges
Some hinge damage, like bending or warping, is pretty evident, but sometimes the damage is subtler. Look for sagging when the door is open or for the door scraping the floor or the door frame.
If it’s a fire door, check that the clearances are still consistently 1/8 in. ± 1/16 in. on the sides and top and 3/4 in. at the bottom. Simple sagging can often be fixed with an adjustment. If a pin is bent, however, you’re looking at replacement. Some clearance issues may be related to the frame, as well.
| Repair | Replace |
| Minor sagging that only requires an adjustment | Any bending or warping that affects the smooth operation of the door or the seal with the frame |
Gaskets and Weatherstripping
Gaskets and weatherstripping are made of softer material that is more easily damaged when the door comes under attack. Since they require proper installation and integrity to make an effective seal, any tearing, holes, or gaps typically means you’ll have to replace it. If the gasket or weatherstripping is intact but has simply been torn free from the door, then you may be able to successfully reattach it.
| Repair | Replace |
| When there are no tears or rips and it can be adequately reattached to the frame | Any sign of a tear, rip, hole, etc. that compromises its ability to create a seal |
The Door Frame
Beside the lockset, the frame is the next most likely thing to need replacing. A door frame must not only remain structurally sound (free of cracks or warping) but also be square, plumb, and level. That is, all sides of the frame need to be flush to themselves and perpendicular to the ground, and the head (the top of the frame) must be level.
Look for any signs that the door hardware has been pulled away from the frame or the frame pulled away from the wall. Look for any signs that screw holes have been stretched or stripped. Some minor gouges or holes in metal frames can be repaired with welding, and small misalignments in metal frames can be adjusted if you know how. When frames become untrue in older buildings, it’s often best to replace the door, too, since the old door may not align or close properly in the new frame.
Rust is a metal door killer. It tends to form from the inside out, so when you see it, it means it’s already inside the frame. If your door frame was damaged in any way by a break-in and it already had rust, take the opportunity to replace it now.
| Repair | Replace |
| Small dents, gouges, or holes that can be patched, small misalignments | Twisting, warping, or bending; structural damage such as cracks or a bent throat (where the frame hugs the wall); damaged strike cutout |
Glass, Vision Lites
Vision lites are the windows in a door or on either side of a door. Obviously, if they are cracked in any way, they will need to be replaced.
If the glass is intact but the seal has been broken, then you can simply replace the gaskets.
Do not try to splice in a piece of gasket. While you may succeed in blocking most airflow, you create tiny penetration points for water and moisture, which can get into your frame and rot or rust it. It’s much cheaper to replace the whole gasket.
| Repair | Replace |
| Glass is intact and only needs new seal | Shattered or cracked glass |
Repair/Replace At-A-Glance
| Repair | Replace | |
| Wood slab | Cosmetic damage like divots or gouges that can be patched with wood filler and painted over. | Structural damage like cracks or holes |
| Metal slab | Minor dents | Holes, or major dents, stretching, or bending near any hardware |
| Lockset | Minor fixes that do not compromise the structural integrity or fire rating and allow it to operate normally | Broken or bent enough that it will never function adequately with any repair |
| Electronic access control | If the unit functions properly and can be affixed to the door or wall without exposing any electronics | If the electronic parts are damaged, the lock does not operate consistently, or you have any of replacement indicators for a mechanical lockset (above) |
| Door closers | Slight bending or simple remounting that does not affect performance | Any friction or warping that impedes smooth movement of the closer arms and/or door |
| Hinges | Minor sagging that only requires an adjustment | Any bending or warping that affects the smooth operation of the door or the seal with the frame |
| Gaskets & weatherstripping | When there are no tears or rips and it can be adequately reattached to the frame | Any sign of a tear, rip, hole, etc. that compromises its ability to create a seal |
| Door frame | Small dents, gouges, or holes that can be patched, small misalignments | Twisting, warping, or bending; structural damage such as cracks or a bent throat (where the frame hugs the wall); damaged strike cutout |
| Glass & vision lites | Glass is intact and only needs new seal | Shattered or cracked glass |
Restore Security with Anderson Lock
We hope this guide helps you get a solid idea of what repairs or replacements your door may need after your break-in, but the safety of your tenants and the security of your building are too important to leave to an unprofessional eye. Unless it’s a quick fix, chances are you’re better off calling in an expert.
Anderson Lock is a local, family-owned and woman-owned business that has evolved alongside the lock and security industry. Our commercial door experts can quickly assess any damage to your door and guide you to the best remedies.
And with a large inventory of commercial doors and in-house fabrication capabilities, our door division makes new door pre-installs and fabrications quick and easy.
Contact us today to have a door tech come inspect your doorway ASAP.
